To comment on this issue, please join on us FaceBook.

To sign up for Family Meals Focus Newsletter, click here

Join Ellyn Satter for the free two-part webinar Preventing Child Overweight and Obesity: Raising Children to be Competent Eaters January 12 and January 19, 2012. Go to https://www2.gotomeeting.com/register/171134530 to register today!

This question recently came around from National Public Radio: “How do you talk to kids about weight, health and body image?” I know they were angling for ways to interest kids in “taking responsibility” for their own size and shape and trying to slim down. In my view, that is simply WRONG. Children are entitled to be free from worry about eating, moving, and weight. Which leaves parents with a LOT to do, starting with maintaining a division of responsibility in feeding. I sent them this excerpt from Your Child’s Weight.¹

Be honest with your child about his or her size and shape. Five-year-old Logan came home from school with the dreaded question. “Am I fat?” he asked his mother. Logan was big - his BMI was at about the 97th percentile, and he had a double chin and a roll of fat around his middle. But he was growing consistently, and his parents were doing an excellent job ensuring that that continued to be the case.* They had regular meals and scheduled sit-down snacks. They kept a firm hand on the television remote control and regularly gave Logan opportunities to run and play. Logan, in fact, was an active child and could keep up with the other children in vigorous play. “You would think he would run some of that off,” said his parents wistfully.

Despite Logan’s electrifying inquiry, his mother kept her cool - to a point. “Why do you ask?” she responded. “We were weighed today in school, and they said my BMI was too high,” he said. “And the other kids teased me - they said I was fat.” At first, Logan’s mother was just mad. How could they do that to him? She made a mental note to go to the school and have a few well-chosen words with the principal. But first things first - she had a question to answer. She got a grip as much as she could on her own upset and did the best she could to be kind and supportive. “Well, no, you aren’t too fat,” she said. “You are just stocky. You have always been that way.” It wasn’t perfect, but it was a good first try. To give her full credit, she avoided saying “Well, we’ll just get you thin, and then they won’t say that.” That would have been hurtful and ridiculous. Hurtful because essentially she would have been saying “You are fat, and that is bad. You are not all right the way you are.” Ridiculous because there was no way she could deliver on an intention to “get you thin,” and trying would only have caused them all a world of hurt.

What is a better answer? Try this: “Why yes, you are sort of fat. Why do they tease you about that?” There is no mild or harmless term that will get you around this question. Chubby is a word that children know full well to mean “fat.” Stocky, chunky, solid, or even buff are words often used by parents and other sympathetic adults to describe the relatively fat child. Those words are appropriate only when used to describe a physically dense child with a lot of muscle mass and bone. For a child who is heavy but not fat, the answer would be, “You are heavier than other children, but you are not fat. You have a lot of muscle and bone.”

When you climb down from your alarm at the possibility of answering a child “Well, yes, you are fat,” consider the issues. Logan was looking for information and help. In giving information, his mother was able to neutralize a message that is often used in a derogatory way. He wasn’t expecting his mother to make a value judgment or to protect him from the slings and arrows of the playground. He just wanted to know. How would it have been different if he had asked, “Do I have freckles?” She could easily have said, “Well, yes, you do. Why do you ask?” For that, she wouldn’t feel responsible. For weight, she would. You know how she feels.

Settle down, and stow your guilt. If you, like Logan’s mother, are doing all you responsibly and realistically can to help your child maintain the body that is right for her, then you need to settle down. Stow your guilt and get on with parenting. Guilt simply gets in the way. You don’t have the child you thought you would have or perhaps hoped to have. Your feelings are your problem, not your child’s. Deal with them, and help your child to cope with hers. If you feel apologetic or treat your child as fragile, she will grow up to blame you and be a whiner.

^{* Logan had about a 60 percent chance of slimming down, but his parents weren’t counting on it. He also had a 40 percent chance of staying right where he was with respect to his size and shape.}

1. Satter EM. Chapter 9, Teach Your Child: Be All You Can Be. Your Child's Weight: Helping Without Harming.. Madison, WI: Kelcy Press; 2005.